MideastWeb Middle East Web Log
Two recent articles discuss the situation in the Saudi monarchy. One says the situation is bad, the other says the situation is much worse than that. A Forbes magazine commentary recently painted the following bleak picture of Saudi Arabia: Turki bin Abdul Aziz Al Saud, a prominent dissident now in exile in Cairo, issued an open letter to his fellow royals, urging them to abandon their desert fiefdom for greener pastures. According to the prince, the current social compact between the House of Saud and its subjects had become untenable, with the government no longer able to "impose" its writ on the people and growing grassroots discontent at the royals "interfering in people's private life and restricting their liberties." His advice? That King Abdullah and his coterie flee the Kingdom before they are overthrown--and before their opponents "cut off our heads in streets."
Turki bin Abdul Aziz Al Saud, a prominent dissident now in exile in Cairo, issued an open letter to his fellow royals, urging them to abandon their desert fiefdom for greener pastures. According to the prince, the current social compact between the House of Saud and its subjects had become untenable, with the government no longer able to "impose" its writ on the people and growing grassroots discontent at the royals "interfering in people's private life and restricting their liberties." His advice? That King Abdullah and his coterie flee the Kingdom before they are overthrown--and before their opponents "cut off our heads in streets."
In contrast, a recent Economist article, When kings and princes grow old, about the Saudi succession, studiously and apparently deliberately ignores Turki Bin Abdul Aziz Al Saud's warning entirely and paints the following fairly rosy picture:
These are seemingly impressive figures. Indeed, the Saudi economy is expected to grow 3.8% in 2010, but that is evidently in nominal terms. Since there is inflation of 5%, the economy is actually shrinking as the population grows.
* In billions. "Real GDP" is adjusted for purchasing power parity. "Nominal GDP" is GDP at the current official exchange rate.
Turkey has a larger economy than Saudi Arabia any way it is measured. Iran has a larger economy in terms of purchasing power. In terms of real per capita GDP, Qatar, with $121,700, is second in the world. Saudi Arabia with a GDP of about $20,000 is ranked 60, but Israel, with only 7.5 million people, and (until 2010) no developed energy resources, has a GDP of over $200 billion and a per capita real GDP of about $28,400 and is ranked 48 in the world. There are no data on the distribution of wealth in Saudi Arabia. That is probably the most problematic and threatening aspect of Saudi economics. There is evidently a very large income differential between the royal family and the poorest classes (see also this NYT article from 2008).
Neither analysis mentions some other ominous factors. The specter of Shi'ite Iran has frightened the Saudis, not least because of a restive Shi'ite minority in south-east Saudi Arabia, where its oil reserves are concentrated. Not only Shi'ites threaten Saudi stability. From the first, it seems that the main goal of Al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden may have been to overthrow and supplant the Saudi monarchy. Bin Laden's 1996 Fatwa was significantly entitled "Declaration of War against the Americans Occupying the Land of the Two Holy Places". In it he writes, among other things,
Both analyses agree that there are problems and signs of increasing instability in Saudi Arabia,. This cannot be good news for the United States, because Saudi Arabia is its prime ally in the Gulf region, and the Americans count on Saudi backing in the war in Afghanistan and in Iraq, though they don't always get such backing.
What reform may not excite the conservatives to violent reaction? What reform may not release the pent up fury of a partially liberated group? Allowing women to vote or drive an automobile? Abolishing the virtue police? Ensuring literacy for females as well as males? Improving the lot of the Shi'a minority?
There is one reform, perhaps that is essential, and that is allowing for a more equitable distribution of wealth, and reinvesting the oil revenues in industry, infrastructure and education. But even that may be dangerous. Some religious conservatives look upon any progress as dangerous. For with industrialization will come a larger middle class and more demands for equality of the sexes. In his book, "In the Anglo-Arab Labyrinth," Elie Kedourie described one source of Arab unrest and resentment of the Ottoman Turks. The Arabs were stirred up by the nefarious Turkish plan to build a railroad to Hejaz. The railroad would of course increase Turkish control in Saudi Arabia, but it would also bring with it dangerous progress. A similar reaction had greeted the introduction of the printing press in Ottoman Turkey itself. That devilish novelty was allowed for Jews and Greeks. When it was introduced for Turks belatedly in 1729, it was quickly suppressed in 1742 and was not allowed again until 1784. In more recent times, the Saudi monarchy was seriously challenged over the dangerous introduction of television:
That quote from a Saudi government press briefing should give us a measure of the problems faced by reform initiatives in Saudi Arabia.
Original text copyright by the author and MidEastWeb for Coexistence, RA. Posted at MidEastWeb Middle East Web Log at http://www.mideastweb.org/log/archives/00000782.htm where your intelligent and constructive comments are welcome. Distributed by MEW Newslist. Subscribe by e-mail to email@example.com. Please forward by email with this notice and link to and cite this article. Other uses by permission.
Replies: 4 comments
Excellent analysis. Compared to recent articles, this has less political propaganda and more insight and illumination of complex geo-political issues of the region. I call for more articles like this one.
Posted by Kiev500 @ 07/20/2010 07:31 AM CST
All that potential is written here indicates hostility, envy, hatred
Posted by ul-jubail @ 09/19/2010 04:24 AM CST
I think that Saudi Arabians are exhausted being excellent host & having too many guest in their country of exterior religion which is not in the best interest of their country in UN geographical maps.
They are one of the nice countries to have invested in their son's education from their nation who were much more refined, kind, excellent students in USA & also navigated through difficult cultural social situations with aplomb.
Their educational system appears to be quite the contrary of being antiquated compared to Texas & most of USA! Engineering students were brilliant, bright, & seemed to breeze through their academics.
The parallel loss of the Shah of Iran weakened the morale of Saudia Arabia
Potholes politics: Televised USA cases. Royal families in Europeon losses
Yugoslavian Bosnian: Anglo Saxon Moslems vs. authentic desert kings.
Desert nations should have invested in buying the Bosnian scientist & other prisoners since they have the best prisons & hosts for Iraqui prisoners which appear to be quite nice & pleasant accommodations. More profitable to invest in a Bosnian scientist handsome nation than USA Louisiana tire treads of underground Russian corruption with lilting accents.
Also, Saudia Arabians were treated very unkindly by American journalist in an interview with king: Guillotining sentences by female journalist. Interrupting the guest until his expressions appeared in a head light eye exam of swinging gestapo light with gauntlet punitive disciplining the actual KING!
Americans have greatly complimented the safety of living in Saudia Arabia & extended tourist to 8 years as opposed to 2-3 in Africa. Multi compliments of Americans feeling much safer in S. A. than in USA.....
Also, art work is nice, pop up Christmas cards are just extremely beautiful & clever designs.
Tall vertical cards with camels & lovely "baseball cards" (term) one would cherish forever.
Saudia Arabians have UFOs which are almost extinct in USA from supposedly being shot out of orbit by unsupervised cretin bases. UFOs are important for equine life.
The news of sad family events in royal families noted across the world...a House Divided, equivalent to War of the Roses British history, always a mordrid lemon in the family, equivalent to Oklahoma state in USA, prehistoric
Mecca: Outstanding articles in National Geographic historically which was enlightning & spiritually edifying equivalent to crusades.
Most expatriates respect the Moslem religion because of the privacey & respectfulness of the culture colonizing this continent with Moslem religion was more effective than Christianity.
Excellent mathematicians. Americans are not excellent mathematicians. Rarely,
Also, I had a miracle experience at a petting zoo as a visitor. Mexican, of course, with kids in front of me. I noted a lovely camel resting to my left, single camel. I had great pianist concentration, foreign student in two other countries, & spoke to this camel in non-words, 'Rise!' (in the name of our Lord.) only in my thoughts pin pointed to this lovliest camel. I am a pianist, also.
This lovliest camel immediately rose! I just couldn't believe it! I had insightful knowledge of a relative, top racehorse breeders entrepreneur baron
A few years later, I was standing next to a horse for sale & prayed for this dignified gentleman. And received two fold wisdom. I knew instantly this horse's lineage, ie, campaign military civil war horse, etc. I turned to the owner & questioned her regarding the history. I was correct! Horse sense
One of the greatest errors Americans have created is failing to "thank" other countries who have greatly prospered USA. Hostile Embassies (trailer court)
Former official diplomatic expatriate.
Posted by BG @ 12/13/2010 08:54 AM CST
please, look at my story and cv photos section in arabic www.facebook.com/israeltwin
Posted by majid almajid @ 01/17/2011 07:11 AM CST
Please do not leave notes for MidEastWeb editors here. Hyperlinks are not displayed. We may delete or abridge comments that are longer than 250 words, or consist entirely of material copied from other sources, and we shall delete comments with obscene or racist content or commercial advertisements. Comments should adhere to Mideastweb Guidelines . IPs of offenders will be banned.
Editors' contributions are copyright by the authors and MidEastWeb for Coexistence RA.
Please link to main article pages and tell your friends about MidEastWeb. Do not copy MidEastWeb materials to your Web Site. That is a violation of our copyright. Click for copyright policy.
MidEastWeb and the editors are not responsible for content of visitors' comments.
Please report any comments that are offensive or racist.
Editors can log in by clicking here