MideastWeb Middle East Web Log
The Oslo process failed because of strong lobbies that militated against peace in both Palestine and Israel. Whatever their numbers, they were organized and succeeded in dictating the public agenda. The peace process will not recover from the Oslo disaster until and unless Israeli and Palestinian political leaders understand that peace is politically viable; that there is a large, organized and dedicated constituency in Israel and among Palestinians that insists on a peaceful future for both people in two states. This constituency will need to take over the political arena, and to outshout the advocates of Greater Israel, "Security," "One State Solution," Sharia law, "Justice," "resistance," and other panaceas that have been obstacles to peace for almost a hundred years.
This constituency is not built in a day. The Onevoice movement has made a start toward building it, by slow and meticulous organizational work in Israel and the Palestinian territories. Last week in Davos, they confronted Palestinian and Israeli leaders with a public plea for peace.
Onvoice Israel Program director Adi Balderman said "The time has come to listen to the voice of the moderate majority, and to prevent violent extremists from hijacking our lives, the lives of millions of Israelis and Palestinians ... We will not accept any more excuses or delays."
From Jerusalem, Saad Mashaal said, "Our city, Jerusalem, open for all
From Ramallah, Nisreen Shaheen told the leaders, "Enough promises, enough excuses, enough suffering ... Help us not to lose hope, help us strengthen this movement, help us strengthen our leaders, that they may sit down at the table and stand up with a fair and lasting peace agreement."
The respective Israeli and Palestinian leaders totally agreed of course. They are all for peace, and they all want peace, only they are not quite ready to do anything about it. Ms. Livni is for peace, and Mr Peres is for peace, but they are building settlements. Mr. Abbas promises peace too, but he is busy making a pact with Hamas to promote "resistance" and turn the guns of the Palestinians against Israel. They are not fooling anyone, are they?
The time has not yet come. The movement must become larger, much larger, and much more insistent. Politeness will give way to firmness and firmness to obstinacy. Polite videocasts in Davos must one day become mass demonstrations in Jerusalem and Ramallah, in Gaza and in Tel Aviv.
Like water on stone, determination and persistence must wear out the hard rock of extremism.
It won't happen until we make it happen. Until then, we will only get more promises.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Contacts In Tel Aviv, Ramallah, Davos & New York Below, Video Footage, Transcripts, and Interviews Available
Ordinary Palestinians and Israelis Ask World Leaders at World Economic Forum in Davos, 'What Are You Willing to Do to End the Conflict?'
OneVoice Movement mobilizes citizens from across Israel, West Bank and Gaza to say 'Enough!'
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni, And
DAVOS, Switzerland, Jan. 25 -- In what Professor Klaus Schwab, Founder and Executive Chairman of the World Economic Forum, termed as the first time ever that ordinary citizens have been able to address their heads of state directly at the Forum, young leaders of the grassroots movement OneVoice were given center stage during a plenary session packed with over 2,000 dignitaries and global business leaders. At the podium, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni and Vice-Premier Shimon Peres each responded to both their citizens and their counterparts with candor.
Professor Schwab introduced the session by explaining, "I have the privilege to share this key session, if not the most important, at this year's meeting." He added, "We thought we should give voice to the ordinary people and you should listen."
A video-cast message from Nisreen Shaheen the Executive Director of OneVoice Palestine -- surrounded by a large crowd of hundreds of Palestinians in Al Qasaba, the largest hall in Ramallah -- appeared on an oversized screen at the front of the forum. Her presentation followed a powerful video showing tens of thousands of OneVoice Israeli and Palestinian activists mobilizing against extremism. She said, "Enough promises, enough excuses, enough suffering ... Help us not to lose hope, help us strengthen this movement, help us strengthen our leaders, that they may sit down at the table and stand up with a fair and lasting peace agreement."
"I've never seen one Palestinian speak with such assertiveness, let alone a group of thousands standing up so clearly for their independence but also for peace," said Bertie Lubner, a Jewish businessman who was in the audience. "It definitely gave me hope that there may be a hidden majority we can talk to on the other side."
Video-cast from Tel Aviv Adi Balderman, the OneVoice Israel Leadership Program Director, stated: "Each and every one of us [needs] to take action and personal responsibility in ensuring a better future. If the millions of moderate Israelis and Palestinians each take a small step, we will unleash the power of the people and reclaim our lives." Addressing elected representatives, she said: "The time has come to listen to the voice of the moderate majority, and to prevent violent extremists from hijacking our lives, the lives of millions of Israelis and Palestinians ... We will not accept any more excuses or delays."
Karim Kawar, Ambassador to the US of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, said, "I was struck by the determination of these young women, flanked by hundreds of like minded young people you don't normally see on TV. Maybe the young leaders we've been waiting for to start standing up and doing something to end this whole mess are finally coming out."
From East Jerusalem Saed Mashaal and Eran Schafferman, OneVoice Palestinian and Israeli Youth Leaders, respectively surrounded by scores of supportive Israeli and Palestinian activists, spoke in unison to condemn violent extremism & intervention from foreign militants. Saed Mashaal said "Our city, Jerusalem, open for all
Eran Schafferman said: "The fate of Israelis and Palestinians is shared and so is our conviction not to let extremist infiltrate and damage our cause for peace and prosperity."
Tzipi Livni, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Israel, said, "After watching together these wonderful youth, after listening to President Abbas, I have a feeling of sadness for lost opportunities, but also a great feeling of hope." She added, "But it is our responsibility as leaders to give them the hope. We must make a promise and fulfill ... the vision of two states living side by side in peace." Minister Livni acknowledged deep skepticism among many that this vision can come about, but explained "We cannot fail" and emphasized the necessity of a realignment of "Moderates committed to a solution vs. extremists opposed to this vision as a matter of ideology. Because we share the same vision, moderates must fight for the same goals ... disempower extremists and empower the moderates."
"The shift in the psychological mindset of the leaders today is of tectonic significance," said Sean Cleary, CEO of Strategic Concepts and a long-time negotiator and mediator.
In spite of very serious tensions, over the last few months, thousands of Israelis, and Palestinians from all across the West Bank and Gaza met under the auspices of the OneVoice Movement to debate and agree on statements representing mainstream nationalists from each side, people that are tired of lack of progress towards ending the conflict. The Founder of the OneVoice Movement, Daniel Lubetzky, attending the Davos session, explained: "We've been building this human infrastructure for five years, and, in spite of the horrible atmosphere, or perhaps because of it, we are gaining more members and more momentum. People are ready to stand up and say, 'Enough!'"
The World Economic Forum is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging leaders in partnerships to shape global, regional and industry agendas. Its Davos Summit is the seminal annual meeting where foremost business leaders, heads of state, and civil society leaders gather to discuss how to improve the state of the world.
OneVoice is a mainstream nationalist grassroots movement with a quarter million Israeli and Palestinian members and 2,000 highly trained youth leaders. It aims to amplify the voice of the overwhelming but heretofore silent majority of moderates who wish for peace and prosperity, empowering them to demand accountability from elected representatives and work toward a two state solution. OneVoice counts on its Board over 60 foremost dignitaries and business leaders across a spectrum of politics and beliefs, joining as OneVoice against violent extremism and for a two-state solution.
Video Footage Available at: http://assets.onevoicemovement.org/video/wef/
Whole session can be seen via webstream, please copy and paste the following link into your browser: http://gaia.world-television.com/wef/worldeconomicforum_annualmeeting2007/default.aspx?sn=19223
Or look for Session: Enough is Enough: Israel and the Palestinian Territories from main webcast page: http://www.weforum.org/annualmeeting/webcasts
TEL AVIV: Raluca Ganea & Nissim Duek, tel +972 3 6874055, cell +972 54 668 0085; email@example.com
RAMALLAH: Nisreen Shaheen, tel +972 2 295 1379, cell +972 599 328 741; firstname.lastname@example.org
NEW YORK: Shelley Shick, tel +1 212 897 3985 x103; shelley@OneVoiceMovement.org
OneVoice Movement Web site: http://www.onevoicemovement.org
For more information and to tell us what you think, please visit our blog:
Original text copyright by the author and MidEastWeb for Coexistence, RA. Posted at MidEastWeb Middle East Web Log at http://www.mideastweb.org/log/archives/00000563.htm where your intelligent and constructive comments are welcome. Distributed by MEW Newslist. Subscribe by e-mail to email@example.com. Please forward by email with this notice and link to and cite this article. Other uses by permission.
Replies: 1 Comment
Realistically speaking, Israel/Palestine has been a de facto "one state" since 1967 - forty years in June - under the complete control of the Israeli Jewish population. There are no viable "two state solutions" on the table at all, just various schemes modelled on either the old Apartheid "Bantustans" or the East European ghettos and neither of these options are sustainable.
Ultimately, the options for a sustainable resolution come down to ethnic cleansing or one democratic secular state for all its people despite religion or ethnicity. While the ethnic cleansing notion has grown in popularity among the Israeli Right, even if ignores the ethical and moral problems, it really isn't a practical possibility for a number of pragmatic reasons. By default, the ultimate resolution will be one state for all its people.
For more reading of diverse views of the matter, see One State Online Bibliography Project @ http://www.onestate.org
Posted by John S. @ 02/22/2007 01:27 AM CST
Please do not leave notes for MidEastWeb editors here. Hyperlinks are not displayed. We may delete or abridge comments that are longer than 250 words, or consist entirely of material copied from other sources, and we shall delete comments with obscene or racist content or commercial advertisements. Comments should adhere to Mideastweb Guidelines . IPs of offenders will be banned.
Editors' contributions are copyright by the authors and MidEastWeb for Coexistence RA.
Please link to main article pages and tell your friends about MidEastWeb. Do not copy MidEastWeb materials to your Web Site. That is a violation of our copyright. Click for copyright policy.
MidEastWeb and the editors are not responsible for content of visitors' comments.
Please report any comments that are offensive or racist.
Editors can log in by clicking here